And the Verdict Reads…


The Premier League arbitration tribunal formed to decided the immediate future of Gabriel Heinze has handed down its decision and the Argentinian will not be making a move to Liverpool.

The panel backed United’s stance that they had made it explicitly clear the defender would not be allowed to join any of their rivals.

For those of you that are fluent in legalese, the League’s statement reads like this:

The hearing concluded that nature and intention of the disputed 13 June 2007 letter, especially when taken in context of verbal discussions and Manchester United FC’s transfer policy, was unambiguous in that it envisages only an international transfer.

Furthermore the hearing finds the letter constitutes an ‘agreement to agree’, and did not create an obligation or binding agreement for the club to transfer the player to any particular club.

In other words the letter is evidence of an intention to negotiate, both between the parties and with potential buying clubs, and not evidence of any intention to create legal relations.

The 29-year old Heinze is able to appeal the decision, but it is unclear whether he actually will. I would imagine because United made it a point of expressing their wishes both in writing and orally, any appeal should prove futile and its probably in the best of all parties to go about their other business.

While I liked the idea of adding Gabriel to the backline, it’s a missed chance I can live with. Heinze has had his share of unfortunate injuries recently, which makes me worry about his body being on the decline. Adding upper echelon talent like his is important and certainly would be useful in a title race, but ideally, I’d like to see Rafa bring in players who are a few years younger, with more potential for growth and a longer shelf-life.

While he’d have slotted in nicely, Heinze appears to have options in Spain (and France with Lyon, but seriously…) as there are rumors of interest from Barcelona and Real Madrid.

Where does this leave Liverpool? Are we still in the market for another defender? Are we looking for another left-sided fullback, a centerback or a utilityman?

With the transfer window set to close in ten days, we’ll have our answers soon.


3 Responses to “And the Verdict Reads…”

  1. 1 georger August 21, 2007 at 12:09 pm

    with paletta loaned to boca we definitely are in the market for cover at centre, and i think we need a new left back, i dont think arbeloa is the answer.

    submitted for your approval i suggest Giorgio Chiellini, the next great italian defender at left back, and Vincent Kompany at centre. the pair could be gotten for around twenty million pounds or less and would be well worth it.

    finnan probably has three years left in him, but i expect darby to be challenging him for playing time next season. but if for the next eight years we had a core of darby, carra, agger, kompany, hobbs, threlfall, insua, chiellini, that would be fantastic

  2. 2 nate August 21, 2007 at 1:43 pm

    I can’t say I’m at all surprised by the decision, and I’m in the same boat as you. Heinze would have been decent cover at two positions where Liverpool could be in trouble if injuries accrue, but yeah, he’s 29, £6.8m is a lot for a backup, and he never showed the same vein of form post-knee surgery.

    I doubt if Liverpool will be in the market now. It seems pretty clear Benitez wanted Heinze, and few other possibilities have been mooted in the media. Now that Heinze’s not possible, I think Rafa will trust what he’s got until at least January.

    I hadn’t seen that Paletta’s loan to Boca had gone through until now, which makes me a bit worried about center back. Insua/Arbeloa/Aurelio (if he ever gets fit) should be enough at left back. However, the examples brought up by georger would probably be too expensive for backup defenders, and neither would get enough playing time where they’d be happy.

    I’d love to see Hobbs or Spearing be 4th choice at CB if needed, but we’ve seen little to be able to make the judgment that they can.

  3. 3 beingsven August 21, 2007 at 1:47 pm

    I liked the idea of Kompany (as did Chelsea and a few others), but he just made the move from to HSV last year.

    We’ve been linked to Chiellini, as there was preseason speculation about his future role at Juve, so that’s certainly an exciting possibility.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

RSS feed



%d bloggers like this: